“Dozens of them. And dozens. And dozens more. (That’s not all I’ve received but it is a significant portion of the responses).
Usually they are just form letters. Something like, ‘Sorry that the work does not fit our needs at this time.’ I’m okay with that. Actually, I prefer it. When editors give advice about what they liked and didn’t like, I always find myself wondering if they even read what I sent them, or if they even can read. Seriously. On the rare occasions when editors give advice, I ALWAYS lose respect for them.
A number of times (with one story in particular) I have received personal notes from the editor that were highly complimentary. I HATE that. There is nothing more frustrating than, ‘This story was very well written and very funny. I’m really sorry I can’t use it.’ When they won’t even buy the stuff they like, it gets very hard to stay optimistic.
Still, even bad rejection letters are better than what seems to be a growing trend: No letter at all. There may be a note in the guidelines saying, ‘Check our blog for submission status.’ Or in some cases, ‘We reply only on acceptance.’ I find theses things unprofessional and annoying. I am beginning to avoid submitting to such markets.”
David Vandervort
—————————————————————————————————————————–
“Gee – nobody who calls themselves a serous writer would claim he never had received a rejection. Actually it is normal to receive many more rejections than acceptance. I have published three e-books and have of course received countless rejections by countless publishers before I got accepted.
Most times you get a standard letter not saying much. It’s like every business project: The other part has to feel comfortable and believe in it, and if they don’t, they’ll reject.”
Eugene Rembor, MBA
http://www.remborpartners.com
—————————————————————————————————————————–
“Gee, no! I’ve had every single thing I’ve ever written accepted…sometimes before I’ve submitted it!! Are you kidding? It just wouldn’t feel like real writing without rejection!
The deal with my agent is this: send me the ones that are so completely off-the-wall that I’ll think they’re funny, send me the ones that say nice things about my writing, spare me the rest.
As a result I have a file of some wonderful rejections letters that inspired me to keep writing. In fact, years later I met that editor at Doubleday when they published my second book and thanked him for his kindness and generosity to an unpublished author.”
Meredith Gould
http://www.meredithgould.com
http://meredithgould.blogspot.com
—————————————————————————————————————————–
“Only about 35. I’m starting a collection.”
Adam Shake
—————————————————————————————————————————–
“Actually yes. Rejection letters are so necessary in this industry that they are to be viewed as excellent signs of progress and participation in the process.
I have been taught that anything that is even vaguely interpretable as less than severely negative should be taken as a strong compliment. For example: Your work does not suit our publishing needs this year.
This is to be interpreted as, ‘You’re work is really very good; keep submitting it until someone says Yes.’”
Miriam Pia
—————————————————————————————————————————–
“I don’t write professionally, and I have quite a number of rejection letters. I framed the one from Marvel Comics. My husband has his rejection letter from Fantasy and Science Fiction magazine framed on his office wall.”
Sherry Foster
—————————————————————————————————————————–
“Hi, Kelly,
Several years ago I submitted a proposal for a crafts/history book to a number of publishers. Admittedly, my book idea was difficult to classify. As a graphic designer, my submission included a mini-chapter laid out with illustrations so publishers could get an idea of what I was trying to accomplish.
I received about a dozen rejection letters. (No surprise.) Most were photocopies of the standard ‘not right for our market,’ etc. I did receive a couple of handwritten notes telling me they loved the idea and the sample I’d enclosed, and suggested other publishers to try. Not being a professional writer, I found their suggestions very encouraging, and also helped me refine my ideas. By receiving a handwritten note, I knew that some human had actually looked at my manuscript. I counted that as a bonus.
I’m working on another iteration of the book and hope to send it out again.
Thanks, Kelly. Good luck with your blog.”
Cathy Palmer
http://palmerdesigns.home.comcast.net/
—————————————————————————————————————————–